Organic food inspections lacking, former inspector says

USDA National Organic Program certifications need to be beefed up

What is in this article?:

  • Organic foods proponents petitioned the government to create a certification program for their crops.
  • USDA has been struggling to develop meaningful testing for those crops.
  • Critic Mischa Popoff believes the testing is too little and too late to adequately detect pesticide residues in those crops.

THE SOUTHERN CROP PRODUCTION ASSOCIATION’s board of directors approved a new slate of officers at its annual meeting in Jacksonville, Fla. Steve Williams, left, front row, with Albaugh Inc., Albany, Ga., was named secretary-treasurer; Jeff Cassady, Bayer CropScience, Reidsville, N.C., is the new president; Ed Duskin, Dawson, Ga.; remains executive vice president; Spencer Black, left, back row, Triangle Chemical Co., Macon, Ga., is the new vice president; and Joe Will, Southern States Cooperative, Richmond, Va., is the immediate past president.

Claims 'unsubstantiated'

Cornucopia’s experts call Popoff’s claims “unsubstantiated” and complain he’s another in a long line of critics such as Dennis and Alex Avery of the Hudson Institute that have challenged the authenticity of the organic food industry’s production and pricing practices.

But even Cornucopia agrees that changes need to be made to the USDA National Organic Program to improve the screening process for “toxic” chemicals in organic foods. “We think there is great merit in doing spot testing, as Congress required, and we have criticized USDA for not having implemented testing until now,” Cornucopia’s Will Fantle said.

The USDA’s National Organic Program is currently soliciting public comments on a new federal ruleoutlining the periodic residue testing of organically produced agricultural products. The proposal calls upon independent organic certifiers to conduct more surprise inspections of organic operations.

Popoff says more is needed than just the current written records with auditors who simply look at the paper trail. He proposes that organic crops be randomly tested in the field in the middle of the growing season to ensure that no herbicides have been applied.

That testing needs to be conducted not only in the U.S. but also in countries that have adopted the USDA National Organic Program standards and ship their products into this country using the USDA certification label.

New Officers

At its annual meeting the Southern Crop Production Association’s board of directors also ratified the selection of Jeff Cassady, a regional manager for Bayer CropScience based in Reidsville, N.C., as its president for 2013-14.

Spencer Black with Triangle Chemical Co. in Macon, Ga., will become vice president; Steve Williams with Albaugh Inc., in Albany, Ga., will become secretary/treasurer; and Joe Will with Southern States Cooperative in Richmond, Va., the immediate past president will become president ex officio. Ed Duskin of Dawson, Ga., will remain executive vice president.

The SCPA also named Ana Cristina Rodriguez, state registration and regulatory affairs manager for DuPont Crop Protection, as the winner of its William C. Larue award for significant service to the SCPA and the crop protection industry.

Rodriguez is currently serving as chair of the SCPA State Affairs Committee and leads the U.S. State Registration Group at DuPont that is responsible for obtaining and maintaining registrations for crop protection and professional products in the U.S.

The SCPA’s Don W. Beise Award for Significant Service was given to Lynne Hoot, executive director of the Maryland/Delaware Agribusiness Association. She also serves as executive director/administrator for six other agricultural associations. The award is given annually to a person outside the SCPA. 

Discuss this Article 2

Paul @ Living Beyond Organic (not verified)
on Nov 19, 2012

Most people believe that products marked "Organic" have gone through rigorous tests and the company who produces the product has their health in the forefront of their mind when supplying products. What people don't know is that "organic" companies are owned by parent corporations who have spent years lowering quality of foods in order to save money on costs and gain a better return.
It all boils down to stock prices not your health. I write about this kind of stuff on my blog trylivingorganic.com Also, check out a company that does organic right! its called Beyond Organic and it's a very respected company started by Jordan Rubin who wrote "Maker's Diet" He also has a blog which regularly talks about organic foods and the truth behind what happens.

I'm excited to see some of the local farmers raising hell, if something has pesticides it just AINT organic.

butleralex62
on Mar 26, 2013

Organic foods are grown without pesticides and uses sustainable way of farming that differentiates them from conventional food. So people have a concept that these foods are healthy and safe. But there are certain companies and people who are using synthetic fertilizers and pesticides that degrades the quality of food. I think government must make a provision to ensure the quality of organic food.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Delta Farm Press ID
(optional)

Continuing Education
Potassium nitrate has a positive effect in controlling plant pests and diseases when applied...
This online CE course details sound mechanical irrigation design and management practices to...

Newsletter Signup