Agriculture facing major changes in child labor laws

‘Sweeping’ changes proposed, family farm exemptions untouched

What is in this article?:

  • New 'sweeping' rules to govern child labor in agriculture proposed.
  • Children of farmers working family operations remain exempted.

 

The right balance?

During the press conference, Labor Secretary Hilda Solis said she was “proud to announce that the (DOL) is proposing revisions to child labor regulations that would provide added safeguards for young workers employed in agriculture…

“Our proposal has important implications for those who work in agriculture. … We’re inviting the public to provide comment on its provisions.”

Solis said the proposed rules are “also part of our effort to better align the rules that apply agricultural employment with those that apply to the employment of children in non-agricultural work places.

“Children employed in agriculture are some of the most vulnerable workers in America. We cannot, and will not, stand by while so many of them continue to work in unsafe and unhealthy work places.

“Though the number of young, hired farm workers is relatively small, they’re employed in one of the most dangerous occupations. Their job duties can range from working with animals to pesticide handling, timber operations, grain bins and complex, power-driven equipment. These are activities best left to trained adults.”

In 2009, said Solis “we found egregious child labor among blueberry farms in several states across the country. We put a stop to it. We made sure employers understood the law and made sure workers understood it, too.

“It is important to note that our proposed rule is designed to strike the right balance. (It) doesn’t change the parental exemption, which allows the child of a farmer to do anything at any age, at any time of day, on a farm owned by his or her parents.”

The public comment period on the new regulations will run through Nov. 1. A public hearing will follow the comment period. The DOL says a complete list of the proposed revisions will be available in the Federal Register on Friday (September 2).

Asked how the new regulations might impact Latino children working U.S. farms, Hancock saidthe DOL’s intention “is to protect all children working in an agricultural setting.  Of course, Latino children and their families are heavily present in that industry. We expect they’ll be one of the primary beneficiaries of this. But the intent is to protect children and we think that’ll be accomplished by this.”

What about restrictions based on age?

All of what the DOL proposes “is within the confines of legislation,” said Hancock. “Legislation not only allows the children of farmers to work unimpeded on the (family) farm without any age restriction, (there are) a number of different exceptions that allow children even under 12 years old to work in agriculture under certain, circumscribed conditions. That’s been in the legislation since the beginning and nothing in (the new proposals) will disturb that.”

So, there’s no minimum age for children working a farm 12 hours a day?

“Again, the legislation is something that sets the parameters on what we can do,” replied Hancock. “Having said that, we think a number of these provisions will have a profound impact on children working in agriculture no matter their age – particularly for children of 14 and 15 years, who will now be prohibited from doing certain occupations they’ve heretofore been able to do.

“In addition, we’re asking for comments on a particular issue about whether or not certain conditions may persist in the agriculture work place that we should take a closer look at. Things like when the heat reaches a certain point and presents a hazard we need to look at.

Again, we think these are fairly sweeping protections we’re extending to all children in the agricultural work place without regard to age.”

Discuss this Article 26

Anonymous (not verified)
on Nov 3, 2011

What the hell more regulation from bais untrained surveyors. How else do you install work ethic? The reason threr are more deaths is like anything else, their the only ones with any drive and now you want them to become couch potatoes. Term limits and less regulation. KISS

Anonymous (not verified)
on Mar 12, 2012

This law pisses me off so much. I live on a farm and i show animals at the fair and i am a part of 4-h and FFA this is ripping my life apart

Anonymous (not verified)
on Mar 17, 2012

I was wondering the same thing about the 4h. I also belonged to 4h. I imagine there will still be 4h, only the children will not be allowed near the animals.

As for working on the farm. I grew up on a farm and the great memories I have are working on farms and learning far more then the kids who do not. Actually, I feel bad for the kids that did not have that chance and have to pay a lot of money just to visit a fake farm to see what it's like.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Nov 30, 2011

We are working on our third generation of people who never had to work because the government gives them an income for doing NOTHING! Our children need to understand what hard work will give you; money in their pocket, and a sense of accomplishment for a job well done. When is this nonsense going to end? In small agricultural communitys, these are the only jobs our teenagers can have. However, in these small towns we have more and more people moving in due to low rent, who do not want jobs because then they won't receive there "paycheck" from Uncle Sam. These are becoming the majority in our community and I do not want my son to EVER think that this is the way to live in society. Earn your keep, work hard and live within your means. It's really that simple.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Nov 30, 2011

Wow, as a parent of a son who works for a farmer part time may I say less regulations please. Our son paid for his first truck,laptop, ect.by running a tiller,harvesting,putting up fence post. He did it on his own and has learned to have pride in a job well done. He gets great joy from the pies or salad made from the fruits and veggie he brings into our home. My spouse and I have three sons hard work never hurt any of them.Today parents are suppose to give children whatever thier little hearts desire. We disagree when a child or teen works for what they want it has more value to them, they choose wisely because it is from thier own toils, sweat,and hard work. Our sons do not ask for bail outs, they look for ways to make the money they need.Our sons are all grown now the youngest mentions above just turned 18, three years of farm work was great for him. Also proud to say in a 'there are noooo jobs' whiny world all three are employed. TCB sons!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Dec 1, 2011

If congress and the Obama Administration would take the time to realize that Agriculture is America's backbone - maybe such laws wouldn't come into perspective for change. We family farmers, agriculturalist, FFA and 4-H members (new and old), do what we do because we love this industry and believe in American Agrilculture. Perhaps take time to read the FFA creed and ask a young agriculturist if they think these new laws will be of benifit. Also, what is this teaching the younger generation? More and more kids are lacking a sense of hard work and determination as other things seem to consume their lives...the young agriculturalist who these laws are focusing on, are the ones that know the meaning behind hard work and see the benefits from doing so! If we're restricting them from learning and practicing the trade of "farm life," how will they ever know how to reap the benefits in the future? "I beleive that to live and work on a good farm, or to be engaged in other agricultural pursuits, is pleasant as well as challenging - for I know the joys and discomforts of agricultural life, and hold and inborn fondness for those associations which even in hours of discouragement, I cannot deny" (a portion of the FFA creed, written by E.M Tiffany). We've seen hard times and good, and felt the blow of discouragement. Remember, Congress - these kids your talking about, do what they do because they want to! It's a way of life which teaches us so much!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 8, 2012

Well said! My own 12 yr. daughter knew immediately how it would impact FFA and 4-H kids along with the kids who participate in youth rodeo events. These kids DO have a great work ethic that the "city kids" have no chance to reflect upon, and unfortunately, do not respect. Thank you for standing up for our Ag Kids!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Mar 22, 2012

I am a 67 y/o male American of Hispanic culture. I was born and raised on a farm in Colorado and learned at a very early age to drive a car, trucks, tractors and other motorized equipment. My brothers and sisters all toiled in the fields to raise many different crops, hoisted hay bales onto trucks and into storage, pulled various inplements behind the tractors and did many jobs which were dangerous. But guess what, we actually learned how to avoid getting injured as we learned to respect the equipment. This informal training is something most kids who are raised on farms learn is some of the most important experiences which prepare you for living a good life. All 13 of my brothers and sisters went on to become good stewards and contributers to various communities, AND, none of us ever got any handouts from the government. All of this experience came in really handy thru-out my life, especially during the 32 years I spent as a fire/fighter/ Captain. I also was a carpenter before, during and after my fire service career. All of my childhood experiences while living on the farm really made me a well rounded individual with-out any hand-outs from the government. I guess these government officials think that they know what is best for us Americans after they get elected to office without any knowledge of "real life" experiences. They are just puppets for the present idiot who calls himself 'President'. He has to go back to being the "community organizer" that he was in the most corrupted city of Chicago.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Dec 3, 2011

To have a law which prohibits kids from working on farms is rediculous given the need in this country for technically trained people in the coming years. My experience as a semi-retired design engineer is that a farm provides the BEST broad learning environment for any future technically trained individuals. While in college many decades ago, an engineering professor commented "I can pick out the farm kids immediately, they are head & shoulders above the others." I observed the same thing throughout my career, as "farm kids" always walked into any situation displaying a significantly broader knowledge backgound than the "non-farm kids" . Yes, a farm environment has dangers, but it's what starts the preparation for the inherent dangers in any career working with high voltage electronics, chemicals, construction, high pressure hydraulics, etc. etc. Do not legislate stupidity!!!

Rancher Mom (not verified)
on Jan 8, 2012

Despite the fact that my 12 year old daughter has been to two funerals of a younger friend that died in an agricultural related death, that does not stop her from carrying on the ranching traditions of riding, sorting, branding, cleaning up after, and caring for the variety of ranch animals we have. It has indeed cautioned her. But like you said, these kids will have a better outlook on the safety issues, concerns, and general common sense of any job position given to them. I have heard over and over that a businessman would rather hire a "farm kid" because of their work ethics. Prohibiting these kids from learning the values of a good day's work, usually at a parent's side, would definately impact agriculture in the very near future. People of this country NEED to understand that their food, and subsiquent by-products come from farms and ranches, not the store!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 14, 2012

You guys are all right...children should work, forego an education, not be subject to labor protection and not contribute to social security and medicare that will ultimately help them. I don't know about you, but I like labor rights and why should the poor (face it, farm workers at mostly poor) not be subject to protection. The American public will pay a few cents more for their food.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Feb 23, 2012

The American public's price of food is cheaper then any other country in the world! Countries around the world can use as much as 50% of their income on food. In America, we used roughly 13% of our income on food. The farmer's that employ teenagers are helping them! In our economy, the job market is limited and adults are taking our jobs! Being a teenager I cannot go out to McDonalds in the summer for employment because all the jobs are already taken. Being raised on a farm I have learned the value of hard work. My college fund was started when I was 9 years old showing animals in 4-H. This law would slay all the kids learning to farm. No Farms. No Food.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 21, 2012

You can be sure that we will pay higher food prices if family farms have to pay outsiders to work the farm and drive tractors. Big-Agriculture's political contributions were sure well spent on this idiocy. I learned a huge amount by working on a farm, including work ethic. It helped me to develop skills as a mechanical engineer. This bill isn't about child migrant labor, it's about family farms. The majority of organic food comes from small family farms, which is a problem for Big Ag & Monsanto.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2012

My son at the age of 6 found a way to work with farm animals at the local livestock commission. He told me that Mondays (the day he worked) were better than the weekend. He is now 8 and unemployed - but most of all heart broken and wondering why he can't continue to work doing what he loved most. He has a work ethic I wish the middle school students I teach had. Do we really need to legislate away the jobs that kids were learning a strong work ethic in?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2012

I a "farm kid" have grown up on a farm my entire life. This law is ridiculous! The first time I drove a tractor I was 6, the first time I tilled a field, raked the hay, stacked hay on the wagon I was 12! I am a very hard working child and I have good working ethics. I take care of a 450 head dairy farm with a breeding stock. I am a 16 year old girl now! If these laws go passed I would be lost. I would have nothing in my life anymore. My passion for my farm life and job is all I know. Im inheridting the family farm when it come time. Being in FFA and having my SAE being my 450 head dairy cattle and my breeding stock with my fields of foliage.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 29, 2012

I am an FFA member, and this is what I believe:

I believe in the future of agriculture, with a faith born not of words but of deeds - achievements won by the present and past generations of agriculturists; in the promise of better days through better ways, even as the better things we now enjoy have come to us from the struggles of former years.

I believe that to live and work on a good farm, or to be engaged in other agricultural pursuits, is pleasant as well as challenging; for I know the joys and discomforts of agricultural life and hold an inborn fondness for those associations which, even in hours of discouragement, I cannot deny.

I believe in leadership from ourselves and respect from others. I believe in my own ability to work efficiently and think clearly, with such knowledge and skill as I can secure, and in the ability of progressive agriculturists to serve our own and the public interest in producing and marketing the product of our toil.

I believe in less dependence on begging and more power in bargaining; in the life abundant and enough honest wealth to help make it so--for others as well as myself; in less need for charity and more of it when needed; in being happy myself and playing square with those whose happiness depends upon me.

I believe that American agriculture can and will hold true to the best traditions of our national life and that I can exert an influence in my home and community which will stand solid for my part in that inspiring task.

The creed was written by E. M. Tiffany

Anonymous (not verified)
on Feb 23, 2012

I Agree. thank you for your comment. :)

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 12, 2012

This is so dumb. I work on a farm and am a single mother. I have been planning to have my son help on the farm when he is old enough for years. I believe the farm will instill good work ethics for his future and the men I work with are great examples/mentors for him. Does this mean he can't even mow the lawn?? That's ridiculous. So many kids these days want things without earning them and I'll be darned if my kid is going to be lazy like that. He has been around farm equipment since he was born! He's also been taught farm safety since he was born! The types of accidents they are talking about can happen to adults too. This just disgusts me!!!

Avon (not verified)
on May 8, 2012

As someone who works on a farm and plans to have her child join her, I would think you'd be appreciative of legislation that would protect your child from being exposed to poison and ensure that he was compensated adequately for the work he did.

The law doesn't ban children from working on farms. It merely protects them from the work that's most likely to kill them. You may be fine exposing your son to the types of accidents that can happen to adults too. But, your son may want to live to be an adult himself and given the number of children who are injured and die on farms, obviously the adults in farming aren't doing enough so the government has to .
I don't like the legislation. But, I don't like kids dying needlessly even more.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 14, 2012

This bill is full of crap. All it is, is a bunch of dumb supervisors that have no clue whats going on saying we should do this so they look important. Their experts are full of crap they have no idea what they are talking about. I grew up on a farm and yes there are some dangerous things but if you have half a brain you wont get hurt.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 18, 2012

The problem is, we are all commenting against this (which is wonderful!) but the bills are going to keep coming and they are on the fast track to being passed. What can we do to stop them???! The government wants to shut the american farmer down so they can sweep up all of the food source. We will be forced to get our food from them. Since when does a government by the people, for the people force them into so many regulations?

Food for thought & heart-wrentching stories that are really happening in our country-http://www.welbornfreedomwatch.org/2012/04/family-farms-under-attack-private.html

I am a sophomore in high school from Minnesota and ACTIVE member of 4-H and FFA, my future is in this industry, it is my life AND my passion. I wish the government would survey other citizens like me who are directly affected by these awful regulations. My future plan is to be a vet and I can't imagine I would have came to that dream without my experiences working on family and neighboring farms.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 26, 2012

Mr. Obama, et.al. have never "worked" a day in their lives!!!! My husband put himself through college milking cows! Doing away with 4H and FFA, what will be next? Boy Scout merit badges for animal raising and care????

Change of subject.....I would like for Mr. Obama to spend a half day sitting in solitude in Arlington National Cemetery. He probably would not "hear" taps being played every 10 minutes across those beautiful grounds. How many "soldiers" lying there were farmers, sons of farmers and might have been fathers/mothers of farmers. Oh, when will reality be possible?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Oct 5, 2012

Yo Obama why don't you pull your head out and stop messing with farm kids. I was raised on 400 acres of cotton, 1,000 acres of pasture and have started my own cattle buissness when I was 10. What your doing is morally and unethically wrong

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 27, 2012

Thank goodness this bill got scrapped!!! We "farm kids" now live in a country where the population has shifted to more urban than rural and it is showing in the way the country is heading. It is time that common sense is brought back to our great country. Where do we start? who knows....maybe term limits, no such thing as a career politician, not letting money or news media sway our vote, less regulation, this list can go on and on and I wish there was a simple answer, but there isn't.....Unfortunately the only people that can get elected are the ones with big business in their pockets and vice versa. I still have hope that someday soon we find a common sense leader with enough power behind them to get this crap turned around....I'm thinking someone with an ag/ffa/4-h background just might be someone who can!!!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 27, 2012

SO thankful this bill got shot down! for now!! As a farmers daughter and a farmers wife and raising our 4 children on the farm, all involved in 4-H and FFA and myself being a county fair manager, I was sick over this! Not knowing what effects might result from this law, and who it would hurt! We just need to stay on our toes get involved and keep current on ag issues!

sroger946
on Jan 8, 2013

The U.S Department of Labor is all sets to prohibit the issues of child labor from the society, as children are the future of the society (country) so they need special attention and facilities such as better education and many others.

Most probably here we can found the DOL (Department of Labor) blames agriculture for responsible of child labor where we found children are working under agricultural jobs. So we are just waiting for that day when we dream for a child labor free country really DOL contributes a lot towards their well being.
abandoned child

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Delta Farm Press ID
(optional)

Continuing Education
Potassium nitrate has a positive effect in controlling plant pests and diseases when applied...
This online CE course details sound mechanical irrigation design and management practices to...

Newsletter Signup